| PICK 1 | Juan Cor (CA) | Shohei Ohtani 2018 T T White Whale Auto Patch 1/1 |
| PICK 2 | thomas hil (CA) | Alex Rodriguez 2018 Flawless Mem Marks Auto 5/5 |
| PICK 3 | thomas hil (CA) | Seager/Valentin 2012 BowSter Dual Auto Plate Blk 1/1 |
| PICK 4 | Juan Cor (CA) | Corey Seager 2016 NT RPA 49/49 |
| PICK 5 | Robert Per (MI) | Mattingly 2001 Donruss Cl Significant Sigs Auto NNO |
| PICK 6 ($25 Credit) | Robert Per (MI) | Cal Ripkin Jr 2005 Donruss Biography Cut Auto NNO |