| PICK 1 | thomas hil (CA) | Joe Montana 2017 Vertex Capstones Quad Relic Auto 1/5 |
| PICK 2 | Jason Gha (OH) | Peyton Manning 2016 Contenders Legendary Auto 10/10 |
| PICK 3 | Justin Gul (PA) | John Elway 2011 Certified Patch Auto Prime 12/25 |
| PICK 4 | James Mon (CA) | Troy Aikman 2016 Flawless HOF Auto 2/10 |
| PICK 5 | Jerry Ken (MI) | Peyton Manning 2004 SP Patch Auto 20/100 PSA 9 |
| PICK 6 ($25 Credit) | Justin Gul (PA) | Terrell Davis 2016 Donruss Sig Series Hologold Auto 3/3 |